Pizza
Grilled Pizza of the Day
Grilled crisp pizza with today’s topping.
$16.00
Margherita Pizza
$16.00
Pepperoni Pizza
$16.00
Rustica Pizza
$16.00
Tilapia Tricolor Pizza
$16.00
Antipasti
Mozzarella Caprese
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted red peppers, and red onion garnished with fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.
$25.00
Calamari Fritti
Marinara sauce and lemon.
$28.00
Calamari “Sicilian Lifeguard” Style
Spicy cherry peppers, capers, marinara sauce.
$30.00
Prince Edward Island Mussels
Fresh tomatoes and basil in a garlic wine sauce.
$28.00
Baked Littleneck Clams
Littleneck clams baked whole, topped with seasoned breadcrumbs and herbs.
$26.00
Scampi Limoncello
Sauteed jumbo shrimp in a lemon, garlic and Limoncello sauce topped with toasted almonds.
$31.00
Stuffed Mushrooms
Spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, diced fresh mozzarella, breadcrumb and cheese.
$22.00
Mozzarella Fritta
Fresh mozzarella julienne zucchini prosciutto “San Danielle” style frisee tomato.
$27.00
Eggplant Rollatini
Breaded eggplant rolled with herb ricotta & prosciutto, topped with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese.
$24.00
Sides
Broccoli
Fresh, cut daily, steamed broccoli with olive oil and garlic.
$12.00
Spinach
$12.00
Escarole
$12.00
Mashed Potatoes
$12.00
Broccoli Rabe
Broccoli rabe, also known as rapini, is beloved for its slightly nutty flavor.
$15.00
Roasted Potatoes
$12.00
Grilled Italian Sausage
$12.00
Chicken Meatballs Marinara
$12.00
Insalata
Mixed Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, olives and cucumbers.
$18.00
Gorgonzola Salad
Mixed greens, red onions, olives, tomatoes, gorgonzola cheese, and walnuts.
$26.00
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, caesar dressing, croutons, shaved padano, and anchovies.
$26.00
Warm Goat Cheese Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, and olives, with warmed bread crumb, crusted goat cheese medallions, topped with toasted almonds.
$26.00
Mushrooms & Asparagus Salad
Sauteed mushrooms, and asparagus with roasted peppers, and mixed greens.
$30.00
Salad Entrees
Grilled Shrimp Salad
Mixed greens, fresh mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, onions and toasted almonds with a citrus shallot vinaigrette dressing.
$40.00
Warm Frisee, Spinach & Chicken Salad
Sliced grilled chicken, roasted peppers, mixed greens, and smoked mozzarella tossed with a warm white wine vinaigrette.
$30.00
Warm Grilled Scallop Salad
Shiitake mushrooms, cannellini beans, fresh tomatoes, and mixed greens tossed with warm white wine vinaigrette.
$45.00
Crispy Calamari Caesar Salad
Crispy fried calamari over a traditional Caesar salad.
$31.00
Pasta
Pasta Marinara
Italian tomatoes, olive oil, basil and garlic. Linguine, penne or rigatoni.
$28.00
Pasta Arrabiata
Italian tomatoes, olive oil, cherry peppers and basil pesto.
$29.00
Pasta Vodka
Tomato cream sauce accented with bacon and prosciutto. Linguine, penne or rigatoni.
$30.00
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Chicken meatballs in marinara sauce.
$31.00
Linguine with Clams
Fresh clams, garlic, extra virgin olive oil in a red or white clam sauce.
$38.00
Linguine Shrimp, Mushroom & Escarole
Garlic wine sauce.
$40.00
Rigatoni Broccoli Rabe & Chicken Meatballs
Fresh tomatoes & cannellini beans in garlic & oil.
$38.00
Rigatoni Butera
Crumbled veal sausage and sweet peas in a tomato cream sauce topped with grana padano.
$38.00
Rigatoni Chicken & Spinach
Diced chicken and fresh spinach in a tomato cream sauce.
$34.00
Rigatoni Chicken & Shrimp Vodka
Tomato cream sauce accented with bacon and prosciutto.
$40.00
Rigatoni Chicken Meatball & Sausage
Classic bolognese sauce.
$38.00
Rigatoni Chicken, Mushroom & Sun Dried Tomato
Crumbled chicken sausage or sliced grilled chicken, with mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, and spinach in a garlic wine sauce.
$36.00
Penne Eggplant
Caramelized onions and fresh mozzarella cheese in a marinara sauce.
$34.00
Penne Sausage, Escarole & Cannellini Beans
italian sausage or crumbled chicken sausage in a tomato garlic wine sauce.
$34.00
On The Lighter Side Dishes
Penne Primavera Lighter Side
Lightly sauteed vegetables in a white wine or marinara sauce.
$30.00
Linguine Grilled Chicken & Mushrooms Lighter Side
Julienne carrots and sweet peas in a white wine sauce.
$34.00
Linguine Shrimp & Scallops Lighter Side
Broccoli, spinach and fresh tomatoes in a white wine sauce.
$45.00
Linguine Shrimp & Grilled Chicken Lighter Side
Arugula and fresh tomatoes in a white wine sauce.
$42.00
Baked Pasta
Pan Baked Chicken Meatball Lasagna
Pink sauce with ricotta mozzarella cheese.
$38.00
Pan Baked Veal Lasagna
Spinach in a pink sauce with ricotta and mozzarella cheese.
$40.00
Pan Baked Seafood Lasagna
Shrimp, scallops, and calamari in a marinara sauce with ricotta and mozzarella cheese.
$44.00
Pan Baked Lasagna Classico
Bolognese sauce, ricotta and mozzarella cheese.
$36.00
Baked Cheese Ravioli
Marinara sauce with mozzarella cheese.
$34.00
Rigatoni Caprese
Pan baked rigatoni with ricotta in a marinara sauce with melted mozzarella cheese.
$32.00
Pollo Entrees
Chicken, Spinach & Roasted Pepper
Mozzarella cheese.
$36.00
Chicken Gorgonzola
Grilled chicken breast, gorgonzola cheese, caramelized onions, fresh tomatoes and melted mozzarella cheese.
$36.00
Chicken Parmesan
Breaded chicken cutlet with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$34.00
Chicken Scarpariello
Chicken breast chunks, Italian sausage, cherry peppers, potatoes, garlic, rosemary, white wine & vinegar. On the bone upon request.
$38.00
Chicken Piccata
Sauteed chicken breast, mushrooms, tomatoes and capers in a lemon wine sauce.
$36.00
Chicken Francese
Mushrooms in a lemon wine sauce.
$36.00
Chicken Marsala
Mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce.
$38.00
Chicken Sorrentino
Eggplant, prosciutto and mozzarella cheese in a red wine sauce.
$38.00
Chicken Tricolor
Lemon wine sauce topped with a tricolor salad.
$34.00
Carne Entrees
Veal Parmesan
Marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$44.00
Veal Piccata
Mushrooms, tomatoes and capers in a lemon wine sauce.
$44.00
Veal Francese
Mushrooms in a lemon wine sauce.
$44.00
Veal Marsala
Mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce.
$44.00
Veal Chop ''Caprese'' Style
Breaded butterflied veal rib chops with tomatoes, garlic & wine sauce & melted fresh mozzarella cheese.
$60.00
Veal Chop ''Milanese'' Style
Breaded butterflied veal rib chops topped with tricolor salad.
$60.00
Sirloin Steak Gorgonzola
Sliced sirloin steak with a dry vermouth gorgonzola cream sauce.
$58.00
Sirloin Steak Marsala
Sliced sirloin steak with roasted peppers and a marsala cream sauce.
$58.00
Sirloin Steak Pizzaiola
Sliced sirloin steak with peppers & onions in a tomato garlic wine sauce.
$58.00
Sirloin Steak Toscana
Sliced sirloin steak garnished with spinach in garlic & oil and a red wine demi-glace sauce.
$58.00
Eggplant Entrees
Eggplant Napoleon
Breaded eggplant layered with herb ricotta, marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$34.00
Eggplant Parmesan
Breaded eggplant with marinara sauce and mozzarella.
$34.00
Pesce Entrees
Shrimp Marinara
Fresh basil.
$38.00
Shrimp Parmesan
Breaded marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$42.00
Shrimp Butera
Tomatoes, garlic, and wine sauce with bacon, sweet peas, and a splash of cream.
$42.00
Shrimp Limoncello
Lemon, garlic and limoncello sauce, topped with toasted almonds.
$42.00
Seafood Marinara
Shrimp, scallops, calamari, mussels and clams in a marinara sauce. Fra diavolo or white wine sauce upon request.
$56.00
Calamari Marinara
Sauteed calamari in a marinara sauce.
$36.00
Tilapia Oreganata
Baked herb & bread crumb topped tilapia filet in a light wine sauce.
$38.00
Tilapia Livornese
Sauteed tilapia in tomatoes, garlic, and wine sauce with olives, capers, red onions, and basil.
$38.00
Lump Crab Crusted Tilapia
Lump crab herb & baked crumb tomatoes, lemon wine sauce.
$40.00
Grilled Salmon Medallions
Herb & bread crumb crust, garnished with grilled asparagus & a dijon wine sauce.
$48.00
Basa Marachiara
Light tomato, garlic, and wine sauce with diced fresh mozzarella cheese and basil.
$38.00
Basa Filet
Shiitake mushrooms and fresh tomato in a lemon wine sauce, topped with almond pangritata.
$38.00
Kids Menu
Kid's Pasta in Marinara Sauce
In marinara sauce.
$8.00
Kid's Pasta in Butter Sauce
In butter sauce.
$8.00
Kid's Cheese Ravioli in Marinara Sauce
In marinara sauce.
$9.00
Kid's Chicken Fingers with French Fries
With french fries.
$9.00
Kid's French Fries with Melted Mozzarella Cheese
With melted mozzarella cheese.
$6.00
Kid's Focaccia Pizza
Focaccia.
$9.00
Desserts
Apple Crostada
A free form flaky crust encasing a warm apple filling garnished with caramel sauce.
$9.00
Amaretto & Almond Cake
Served warm with vanilla ice cream and a delicate amaretto sauce.
$9.00
Tiramisu
Mascarpone cream, ladyfingers & espresso, sprinkled with chocolate.
$9.00
Fudge Brownie Butera
Rich chocolate brownie topped with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream & chocolate syrup.
$9.00
Chocolate Chip Pie
A timeless classic served warm with vanilla ice cream.
$9.00
Cannoli
A traditional favorite with Butera's own homemade filling.
$8.00
Tartufo
Chocolate encrusted ice cream with cherries & nuts.
$8.00
Butera Brownie
Brownies served warm with 4 scoops of vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, candied walnuts & maraschino cherries. For 2 pieces.
$20.00
Lunch Grilled Pizzas
Margherita Pizza Lunch
Marinara and melted fresh mozzarella.
$15.00
Pepperoni Pizza Lunch
Our traditional Margherita with imported pepperoni.
$16.00
Rustica Pizza Lunch
Homemade crumbled chicken sausage, melted fresh mozzarella and grape tomatoes.
$16.00
Lunch Salads
Grilled Shrimp Salad Lunch
Jumbo shrimp with mixed greens, diced fresh mozzarella, tomato, onion, and toasted almonds over bruschetta points with a citrus shallot vinaigrette.
$21.00
Warm Frisee, Spinach & Chicken Salad Lunch
Sliced grilled chicken, roasted peppers, mixed greens, and smoked mozzarella tossed with a warm white wine vinaigrette.
$18.00
Warm Grilled Scallop Salad Lunch
Jumbo sea scallops with shiitake mushrooms, cannellini beans, fresh tomato and mixed greens tossed with a warm white wine vinaigrette.
$22.00
Crispy Calamari Caesar Salad Lunch
Crispy fried calamari over traditional Caesar salad.
$18.00
Mushroom, Asparagus & Grilled Chicken Salad Lunch
Sauteed mushrooms and asparagus with sliced grilled chicken mixed greens and roasted peppers with our house vinaigrette.
$20.00
Tilapia Tricolor Salad Lunch
Grilled tilapia fillet served with fresh tomato salsa and a tricolor salad.
$14.00
Soup & Salad Lunch
A bowl of our hearty soup of the day complete with your choice: a small goat cheese, gorgonzola, Caesar or mixed salad.
$15.00
Lunch Grilled Burgers
Char Grilled Chicken Veggie Burger Lunch
Freshly ground chicken, fresh diced zucchini, red peppers, carrot and onions on a focaccia burger roll.
$16.00
Sauteed Mushroom Burger Lunch
Chargrilled beef burger with sauteed mushrooms, melted mozzarella cheese and basil pesto on a focaccia burger roll.
$16.00
Italian Cheeseburger Lunch
Char grilled beef burger with sautéed peppers and onions topped with melted provolone on a focaccia burger roll.
$16.00
Gorgonzola Burger Lunch
Chargrilled beef burger with fresh tomato, caramelized onions, bacon, melted mozzarella and gorgonzola on a focaccia burger roll.
$16.00
Lunch Wraps
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap Lunch
Sun-dried tomato wrap with grilled chicken and Caesar salad.
$16.00
Chicken Cutlet Wrap Lunch
Fresh mozzarella, baby arugula, red onion and tomatoes with Italian dressing and pesto on an herb wrap.
$16.00
Steak Wrap Lunch
Sliced grilled sirloin, sautéed mushrooms, caramelized onions and mesclun with sun-dried tomato pesto on a sun-dried tomato wrap.
$19.00
Grilled Chicken & Smoked Mozzarella Wrap Lunch
With fresh spinach, roasted peppers and basil pesto mayonnaise on a black bean wrap.
$16.00
Grilled Chicken, Prosciutto & Fresh Mozzarella Wrap Lunch
With mixed greens, herb ricotta and sun-dried tomato pesto on a herb wrap.
$16.00
Lunch Focaccia Sandwiches
Grilled Eggplant Focaccia Sandwich Lunch
Served open-faced with caramelized onion and marinara sauce on focaccia.
$14.00
Grilled Sirloin Steak Focaccia Sandwich Lunch
Sliced and served with crispy onions and melted mozzarella on focaccia.
$19.00
Grilled Chicken Focaccia Sandwich Lunch
Served open-faced atop focaccia with tomato salsa.
$15.00
Chicken Parmesan Focaccia Sandwich Lunch
Breaded chicken breast, marinara and melted mozzarella on focaccia.
$16.00
Grilled Chicken Gorgonzola Focaccia Sandwich Lunch
Gorgonzola, fresh tomato, caramelized onions and melted mozzarella on focaccia.
$16.00
Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Pepper Focaccia Sandwich Lunch
With mixed greens and Italian dressing on focaccia.
$16.00
Grilled Chicken Sorrentino Focaccia Sandwich Lunch
Eggplant, prosciutto, marinara sauce and melted mozzarella on focaccia.
$16.00
Grilled Chicken, Spinach, Roasted Pepper Focaccia Sandwich Lunch
With melted mozzarella on focaccia.
$16.00
Grilled Tilapia Fillet Focaccia Sandwich Lunch
Roasted pepper, sun-dried tomato and mixed greens on focaccia.
$16.00
Shrimp Marechiara Focaccia Sandwich Lunch
Served open-faced with a tomato garlic wine sauce and fresh mozzarella on focaccia.
$20.00
Lunch Heroes
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Hero Lunch
Grilled Italian or crumbled chicken sausage paired with sauteed broccoli rabe on a hero.
$16.00
Sausage & Peppers Hero Lunch
Grilled Italian or crumbled chicken sausage smothered in sauteed peppers & onions on a hero.
$16.00
Fried Calamari ''Po Boy'' Hero Lunch
Fried calamari tossed in our famous spicy ''Sicilian Lifeguard'' sauce on a hero.
$17.00
Basa Filet Hero Lunch
Lightly breaded and fried fillet of basa with mixed greens, tomato, red onion and a homemade tartar sauce on a hero.
$16.00
Lunch Pasta Dishes
Rigatoni Broccoli Lunch
Sautéed in a garlic sauce.
$16.00
Pan Baked Rigatoni Lunch
Tossed with marinara, ricotta and melted mozzarella.
$16.00
Rigatoni Alla Vodka Lunch
In a tomato cream sauce, accented with bacon and prosciutto.
$16.00
Penne Chicken Meatball Marinara Lunch
With our famous chicken meatballs.
$16.00
Rigatoni Alla Rosa Lunch
Crumbled chicken sausage and spinach in a pink sauce.
$16.00
Penne Primavera Lunch
Fresh seasonal vegetables sautéed in a white wine or marinara sauce.
$16.00
Lunch Packages
Lunch Package #1
House salad with house vinaigrette, one choice of entree served with potato & sautéed vegetables & cheesecake. Includes unlimited soda, coffee, or tea & fresh baked focaccia & garlic knots.
$240.00
Lunch Package #2
House salad with house vinaigrette, penne marinara, one choice of entree served with potato & sautéed vegetables & cheesecake. Includes unlimited soda, coffee, or tea & fresh baked focaccia & garlic knots.
$260.00
Butera's of Sayville
Sample the best pizza Sayville has to offer at a local independent pizza restaurant. Butera's of Sayville is one of Sayville's most popular. Give them a try, and you'll soon understand why. It's not just pizza. You can also find pasta, sandwiches, and other side dishes at independent pizzerias in Sayville Try something new and expand your culinary horizons. No trip to Sayville is complete without trying the famous Grilled Shrimp Salad. See what all the fuss is about with this local favorite. Try cannoli with your pizza. If you have a family to fee or just a big appetite, you can make your meal into a feast! Butera's of Sayville has been a Slice partner since 2017. They've been serving the local community for a while now, so you can rely on them providing great pizza. Pick up your pizza at Butera's of Sayville with curbside pickup. It makes picking up a meal easier than ever. This local favorite has multiple locations, so there's no excuse not to visit. Find your local branch and enjoy what they have to offer. You can pay by credit card at Butera's of Sayville. That makes it easy to get your pizza as quickly as possible.
Full Hours